« Baker Brothers Blog

A working water heater is essential for any home, providing hot water for showers, dishes, and laundry. But like any appliance, water heaters don’t last forever—and when problems arise, many homeowners wonder: Should I repair my water heater or replace it entirely?

This guide will help you understand the key signs of wear, when a simple repair will do, and when it’s smarter (and more cost-effective) to upgrade to a new unit.

💡 Understanding Your Water Heater: The Basics

There are two primary types of water heaters:

• Tank-style (standard storage water heaters)

• Tankless (on-demand water heaters)

Each has different lifespans, efficiency levels, and maintenance needs, but both can experience issues like leaks, heating element failure, sediment buildup, or inconsistent hot water.

🔍 When to Repair Your Water Heater

Many common water heater problems can be solved with basic repairs or part replacements, especially if the unit is relatively new.

✅ 1. The Unit Is Less Than 8 Years Old

Most traditional water heaters last about 8–12 years. If yours is younger than 8 and hasn't had major issues before, it’s usually worth repairing.

✅ 2. The Problem Is Minor or Isolated

Common repairable issues include:

• Faulty thermostat or heating element

• Tripped breaker or blown fuse

• Loose or damaged pressure relief valve

• Sediment buildup (flushing the tank can help)

If these are caught early, a licensed plumber can often fix the issue for a few hundred dollars or less.

✅ 3. No Visible Tank Corrosion or Major Leaks

Surface rust, leaks from fittings, or condensation can sometimes be fixed. But if you notice corrosion on the tank itself, that’s usually a sign of a more serious problem (we’ll cover that below).

🛑 When to Replace Your Water Heater

At a certain point, continuing to repair an old or inefficient water heater becomes a waste of time and money. Here are the signs it's time to invest in a new system.

🚫 1. The Unit Is 10+ Years Old

If your tank water heater is more than 10 years old—or your tankless unit is over 15—it’s near the end of its expected lifespan. While it may still work, breakdowns become more frequent, and energy efficiency declines.

Pro tip: You can check the age by looking at the serial number on the manufacturer's label. It usually includes a date code.

🚫 2. You’re Constantly Running Out of Hot Water

This may mean your household has outgrown your current unit’s capacity, or that the heating element is failing. If you’ve already replaced parts but the problem persists, a new, larger unit may be the best solution.

🚫 3. Rust-Colored Water or Visible Rust on the Tank

Rusty hot water is often a sign of corrosion inside the tank—especially if you only see it when using hot water. This could indicate the anode rod has deteriorated, allowing rust to form and eat through the tank lining. Once the inside of a tank rusts, it’s beyond repair.

🚫 4. Water Around the Base or Significant Leaks

A leaking tank usually means a crack in the metal due to years of expansion and contraction. This type of damage is irreversible and requires a full replacement.

🚫 5. Your Energy Bills Are Increasing

Old or inefficient water heaters use more energy to maintain hot water. Upgrading to a high-efficiency or ENERGY STAR®-rated model can lead to noticeable monthly savings.

🔁 Repair vs Replace: Quick Decision Chart

SymptomLikely SolutionWater heater under 8 years oldRepairNo hot waterRepair (element or thermostat)Rust-colored waterReplaceVisible corrosion or leaksReplaceFrequent repairs neededReplaceRising energy billsReplaceHot water runs out too quicklyDepends – consult plumber

💸 Repair and Replacement Costs: What to Expect

Average Cost to Repair:

• Minor repairs (thermostat, valve, heating element): $150–$350

• Flushing sediment: $100–$200

• Replacing anode rod: $100–$300

Average Cost to Replace:

• Tank water heater (40–50 gallons): $1,000–$2,500 (installed)

• Tankless water heater: $2,000–$4,500 (installed)

• High-efficiency models: May cost more up front but save energy long-term

🔋 Should You Upgrade to a Tankless Water Heater?

If you’re replacing your system, consider whether a tankless model is a smart fit for your home.

Pros:

• Hot water on demand

• Space-saving design

• Higher energy efficiency

• Longer lifespan (15–20 years)

Cons:

• Higher initial cost

• May require gas line upgrades

• Not ideal for large households with simultaneous water usage (unless properly sized)

🛠️ Maintenance Tips to Extend Lifespan

Whether you repair or replace, proper maintenance can extend the life of your water heater:

• Flush the tank annually to remove sediment

• Check the anode rod every 2–3 years

• Test the pressure relief valve regularly

• Keep the thermostat at 120°F for safety and energy savings

• Schedule annual inspections with a professional plumber

🏠 Final Thoughts: Know When to Act

Water heaters are easy to take for granted—until they stop working. Knowing when to repair vs when to replace can save you hundreds (or even thousands) of dollars and ensure your home stays comfortable year-round.

If your water heater is over 10 years old, leaking, or rusting—it’s time to replace.
If it’s under 8 years and the problem is minor—a repair should do the trick.

📞 Need Help with Water Heater Repair or Replacement?

Our licensed plumbers can help you decide what makes the most sense for your home and budget. We offer free estimates, same-day service, and expert installation for all major water heater brands.

Contact us today to schedule your water heater inspection or replacement!

Contact us or give us a call at 214-892-2225 to schedule your consultation with our licensed experts, who have been serving the DFW community for over 75 years.